There are countless dietary trends and fad diets, making it difficult to decide which one, if any, might be right for you.
Every few years, a new diet seems to appear and dominate headlines, often backed by celebrity endorsements.
For anyone trying to find a sustainable, healthy way to manage weight and improve wellbeing, it can be challenging to know which diet will deliver realistic results and which may not suit you at all.
This article compares four well-known dietary patterns to help make the information easier to navigate.
Paleo Diet
The Paleolithic or “caveman” diet is based on the idea of eating pre-agricultural, hunter-gatherer foods—those that could be hunted or gathered naturally.
What it involves
The Paleo approach excludes:
- Processed meats
- Wheat and dairy
- Refined sugars
- Grain-based foods
And includes:
- Lean meats
- Fish
- Fruits and vegetables
- Nuts and seeds
- Eggs
This pattern is naturally high in protein and lower in carbohydrates.
Pros
- Reduces intake of processed foods and encourages nutrient-rich options.
- Simple to follow, with no calorie counting required.
- Allows flexibility with an 80/20 approach.
Cons
- Relies heavily on meat, unsuitable for vegetarians.
- Excludes dairy and grains, limiting dietary balance.
- Lacks strong scientific evidence of long-term benefits.
Summary
The Paleo diet removes some essential food groups and may cause nutrient deficiencies, but modified versions that include whole grains and dairy can offer more balance. Exercise remains important for healthy results.
Keto Diet
The ketogenic (keto) diet, long used in medical settings for epilepsy, has recently gained popularity for weight management. It involves consuming 25–35 grams of carbohydrates daily (about one apple’s worth), with around 5% of calories from protein and 70–80% from fat.
The goal is to switch the body’s fuel source from carbohydrates to fat-derived ketones. When carbohydrate intake is low, the liver produces ketones from fat for energy instead of glucose. Some followers monitor ketone levels to ensure consistency.
Pros
- Can lower insulin levels and reduce inflammation.
- May lead to short-term weight loss due to reduced appetite and lower water retention.
- Encourages higher intake of healthy fats from foods like avocado, nuts, and fatty fish.
- Reduces consumption of high-sugar foods, helping to curb sugar cravings.
Cons
- Requires strict adherence and extensive meal planning.
- Some may rely on unhealthy saturated fats rather than nutrient-rich options.
- Can be hard to sustain long term, limiting effectiveness.
- Often low in dietary fibre, which can affect digestion and gut health.
Summary
For those trying keto, choose healthy fats like eggs, avocado, nuts and olive oil, include plenty of low-carb vegetables, stay hydrated, and track your wellbeing. It’s best to consult a healthcare professional before starting.
5:2 Diet
The 5:2 or “Fast Diet,” inspired by intermittent fasting, became popular after the BBC documentary *Horizon* in 2012. It involves eating normally five days a week and reducing calorie intake on two non-consecutive days to about 500 for women and 600 for men.
Example fasting day meals include:
- Two scrambled eggs with ham (around 300 calories)
- Grilled fish with vegetables (around 300 calories)
Pros
- Requires calorie restriction only two days per week.
- Simple guidelines to follow.
- Can effectively reduce calorie intake and promote fat loss.
Cons
- May cause fatigue, irritability and headaches on fasting days.
- Possible sleep disturbances and dehydration.
- Can lead to overeating on non-fast days.
- Not all versions are supported by scientific evidence.
Summary
Although flexible, fasting diets may not suit everyone and can affect energy levels. Seek advice from a dietitian or GP before starting, especially if you have health conditions such as diabetes or are pregnant.
Dukan Diet
Developed by French physician Dr Pierre Dukan, this plan emphasises high protein and low carbohydrates to encourage fat burning. It involves four phases: Attack, Cruise, Consolidation and Stabilisation.
- Attack: 1–10 days of lean protein, oat bran and water, with no vegetables or carbs.
- Cruise: Gradually reintroduces non-starchy vegetables and a little extra oat bran.
- Consolidation: Adds daily vegetables, one fruit, some cheese and whole grain bread, plus occasional “celebration” meals.
- Stabilisation: Allows normal eating six days a week; one day follows Attack rules with daily oat bran and exercise.
Pros
- Rapid early weight loss may motivate adherence.
- Simple rules and approved food lists reduce confusion.
- Unlimited portions of permitted foods during the first phase.
Cons
- Can be hard to maintain in early stages.
- Low carbohydrate intake may cause tiredness and constipation.
- May not be suitable for individuals with heart, kidney or metabolic conditions.
Summary
The Dukan diet’s restrictive phases make it difficult for long-term use. More research is needed on its safety and sustainability. Always consult your GP or a dietitian before starting any structured diet, especially if you have chronic health conditions.
“
